« Have Yourself a Merry Little War on Christmas | Main | Opposing Creationism vs. Opposing Religion »

December 28, 2006

How Wrong Do Creationists Claim that Evolutionists Are?

Richard Dawkins has an article on the Guardian's comment is free web site. Dawkins explains how massively wrong mainstream science must be for Old Earth Creationism to be correct.

"First, the age of the Earth. McIntosh thinks, on biblical authority alone, that it is less than 10,000 years. We establishment fuddyduddies think, using mutually corroborating evidence from many sources including several different radioactive isotopes in the rocks, that it is about 4.6 billion years. I shall not say here why I think we are right and McIntosh wrong. Instead, I shall simply calculate the magnitude of the difference between the two estimates. We of the "establishment" think the Earth is 460,000 times older than McIntosh's estimate. It is as though McIntosh estimated the height of a man as 6 feet and then accused the rest of us of believing that the same man was 460,000 times as tall, or 521 miles. Or, looking the other way, it is as though McIntosh looked at the establishment geographers' measurement of the distance from New York to San Francisco and claimed that the true distance from sea to shining sea was 460,000 times smaller, namely about ten yards. Maybe McIntosh is right and all the rest of us wrong. All I have done here is calculate how spectacularly wrong we would be, if McIntosh is right."

read more | digg story

Submit to Digg | Submit to Reddit

December 28, 2006 in Creationism and Evolution | Permalink


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference How Wrong Do Creationists Claim that Evolutionists Are?:


The comments to this entry are closed.